No, I agree. Looking at the actors, it's all over the place in terms of the ordering. I'm not sure if I agree with you on Jamie Bell in particular :-) but there is no way, with his recent work, Elijah would be ranked over people like Ryan Gosling, James McAvoy and Joseph Gordon-Levitt (and probably some others such as Shia, Paul Dano etc.).
BTW James McAvoy needs to lose his scruff even worse than Elijah: if you have brown hair and your beard grows red, it's just a complete no go.