Well, to me the whole idea of the community to find and provide Elijah news/pics, not to comment or speculate on those findings. I guess if everyone kept their opinions/speculations (both positive and negative) to their own LJ, then you would have less to deal with.

Like I mentioned in my own LJ post, discussions should be done in private LJ's and not within a public community. If I want to re-post a pic and say "Pam looks happy/sad/pissed" or "Elijah seems stand-offish/tense/thrilled" than that is my prerogative and what transpires is MY problem- not that of the whole community at large.

Good luck with whatever you ultimately decide.